Why do really successful traders never share their methods or strategies?

104 Answers
Default Recent
颜小明
  • Don't be superstitious about "strategy"!

First of all, some successful traders will share their strategies, such as the famous public trading system turtle trading method.

All that aside, I believe that those who ask these questions a lot, and those who ask me or my trading friends about strategies, are misunderstood about "strategy" itself. A "strategy" is not a blueprint for success, nor is it a top secret worth a trader's life protecting that will allow a trader to magically "dig" money out of the market.

This is the truth, but some people don't want to believe it.

Traders with a few years of experience don't ask about a strategy at all, they ask more detailed questions like: Which market signals do you believe in? What are the entry/exit conditions? Which order type to use? Why?

Then, they began to ask more detailed questions, for example, how to face the loss caused by the mismatch between trading strategy and market behavior? How to find out the market conditions suitable for a certain trading strategy? When do market conditions usually appear for this trading strategy etc...

Novices need not strategy, but experience. If they find competent people who are willing to provide guidance and help them gain experience faster, they can create or implement trading strategies.

Newbies spend a lot of time asking questions, but I hate to spend that much time on everyone who asks. Don't get me wrong. I am happy for everyone who has found success with my strategy. I'm also proud that the strategies I've shared have improved the financial situation of quite a few traders, but at the end of the day: my job is trading, not teaching.

  • "Strategy" is too valuable to share!

There are obvious reasons why most truly successful traders do not share their strategies. It's hard to imagine a skilled professional trader coming home from get off work and teaching people how to trade online. It's even harder to imagine them spending more time teaching than trading.

Traders profit when they have an edge. Imagine if you are a long-term profitable trading master, when you find this advantage in yourself in the market behavior, it is very valuable to you, if it may become invalid after sharing it with others, then you will Wouldn't you share your advantage with others? Neither will you, let alone share it for free, and this advantage is your trading strategy.

It is undeniable that there are also some profitable traders who are willing to share their wisdom about trading and the market. Some of them want to use this to build their own business, build their own brand, increase their career opportunities, some want to sell such strategies to get extra income or make more money to do transactions, and some Maybe it's just because I happen to have a little spare time and want to provide someone with a little value, or just to talk about something they're passionate about. But in any case, it is rare for you to meet a truly successful trader who will teach others to trade.

  • The reasons vary from person to person!

A lot of profitable traders have found the knack of trading, but they only focus on making trades for themselves, waiting for profits, and don't think about others.

Greedy traders don't want their strategies to be taken advantage of by others.

The average trader fears that his strategy will not work if he shares it.

Some traders may worry that others can make more money than they do using the same strategy.

Some traders feel that there is some kind of competition in trading, just like in other industries.

  • Busy with my own business and life~

There are indeed some professional traders who share their strategies with retail investors. But in general, most professional traders seldom do this, mainly because they are busy trading their own accounts.

Second, they don't want the hassle, and they don't care about the money they get from teaching the strategy. Because there are some professional traders who literally live the dream life. They spend a few hours, or a day trading, and the profits they get can make their lives very nourishing. And dropping all of that in order to teach a group of retail traders how to trade is not something everyone can do.

  • Transactions cannot rely on others!

Many traders are secretive and won't tell anyone about their trading strategies.

They spend a lot of time and energy developing their own strategy, if it were you, would you tell the world how you make money? It is not ruled out that some traders will help others and tell them their own strategies.

But most professional traders believe that traders need to do their own trading and analysis, rather than relying on others to easily acquire trading skills.

  • A good trader ≠ a good teacher!

I don't know what your job is, but would you spend time every day teaching newbies? Even if you would, most probably wouldn't.

The teacher's task is not easy at all, even sometimes boring, sometimes frustrating. So most people in any field don't want to be teachers. Furthermore, a successful, professional trader does not necessarily make a good trading teacher.

  • You are the crux of the matter!

That's not to say they don't want to share it with you. Trust me, they will. They will even write books and make videos to teach you how to trade. But, you are the crux of the matter, and you are the one who puts the strategy into practice.

There is a difference between understanding strategies and applying them, and if they were the same, we would have physics without engineering.

Successful traders share their strategies, and they do so often. But I've found that most of the sharing doesn't tell you exactly how to find the right conditions to apply these strategies. Of course, the appropriate conditions mentioned here do not refer to appropriate platforms and funds.

Mark Douglas (Mark Douglas) said: "Successful trading is 80% psychological and 20% technical".

So, don't worry too much about strategy. I suggest you only master a few. Like I have only mastered 2 and I believe there is no need to master more. Therefore, the most important thing is to grasp the market conditions applicable to the strategy, and do a good job of psychological construction, so that the strategy can work without human interference.

  • Why share?

Successful traders are extremely rare, and becoming one is extremely difficult. So why would they give away the keys to their success for free?

90% of trading depends on emotion, 10% depends on strategy, and the other 90% needs to participate in the market, and learn by yourself after losing money. Strategies can be learned, but experience cannot be learned. You need to practice and gain experience by yourself.

  • Even if you teach it, you may not know how to operate it!

People tend to look for a "magic bullet" for their strategy and assume that successful traders are successful because they have encountered one or invented one themselves. This is not the case, and no strategy will make you 100% profitable.

Most success comes from experience trading the markets. Successful traders know when is the best time to trade and when to exit to minimize losses. Plus, they have all sorts of other skills that many novices don't have. The above valuable experience is based on their rich trading experience, even including the painful experience of losing their own hard-earned money.

So, even if successful traders decide to share their highly profitable strategies, most novices won't know how to do it. Because they may get out early, they may be overweight, or they will get out as soon as they start losing money, and finally give up this strategy. It's like asking a 10-year-old to drive a Lamborghini - even though they know the basics of driving a car (braking, accelerating, steering), the actual driving process is far more complicated than they expected.

  • The little-known "secret"~

Professional traders do not expect most retail investors to become trading experts. Because retail investors provide liquidity to professional traders, allowing them to exit trades when retail investors enter the market.

As an example, professional traders take positions long USDJPY 6-12 months before an event and then close out when the news breaks that they are long USDJPY. Retail traders imitated professional traders and also went long on the US-Japan pair, but by then, professional traders had already stepped out.

This can only happen if the broker provides sufficient liquidity, which is provided in part by retail investors.

482 Upvotes
40 Comments
Add
Original
mu qiannuo

It's not that you don't share, but that it's useless to share. All successful traders have grown up after years of tempering, multiple liquidations, and multiple nights of torture. Their trading ideas require a huge knowledge system, and they need to overcome various inner weaknesses, not just a few words Get it done.

But latecomers always want to have some peerless cheats. They don’t want to pay tuition and energy, and don’t want to be respected enough. They can’t ask for advice humbly. Moreover, the level of thinking of a stable profit is something that those who are open to money can understand. In addition, learning to trade is a long process, and there are many people who give up halfway. Why do masters hold back when they are full of expectations? I have seen this kind of person a lot, who would teach others again?

230 Upvotes
24 Comments
Add
Original
容纳百川

Every master has his own trading system, but these trading systems are only suitable for him. Because the formation of this successful trading system requires years of revisions, overthrows, and revisions before it can finally be formed. The trading system is integrated with this person, and it is useless for others to take it. The classic trading system was made public 100 years ago, but today, 100 years later, there are still very few people who make stable profits. Because most people will face the following problems after seeing a successful trading system of others:

1. Doubt whether this trading system can really achieve profitability;

2. I can know every rule of this trading system, but I don't know why;

3. This trading system uses a 4H cycle, and I am not used to the operation of this cycle;

4.. . . . . . .

That is to say, the most difficult thing is not to obtain a stable and profitable trading system, which can be obtained by everyone. The most difficult thing is to understand the trading system, implement the trading system, and believe in the trading system without doubt. Therefore, to achieve this, only after years of experience, you have formed a trading system that suits your own personality, you will fully understand, trust, and unconditionally implement this trading system, because you know why each rule is so Sure, those are the rules that you set after you lost real money, and only in this way can you implement them.

This is why truly successful traders are reluctant to share their methods or strategies because no one else can use them.

If a trading system can make a trader successful, then write the trading system in the textbook, and everyone who learns it can become a billionaire​.

The Yitian Sword is a magical sword, but can everyone who gets the Yitian Sword become the best in martial arts in the world? No matter how good the Yitian Sword is, it is just a sword. The trading system, like Yitianjian, is just a tool. Whether one can become a master or not depends on the person. ​

872 Upvotes
22 Comments
Add
Original
jin buhuan

I believe that truly successful people must have the virtue of sharing and inheritance, don't you believe it? Anyway, I believe it, such as Livermore, Soros, and our contemporary Zhejiang C in China, overseas returnees, have been engaged in it for about six or seven years. The PA public welfare practice platform spares no effort to spend a lot of time and energy, and teaches PA simple techniques and strategies with great enthusiasm and patience. I admire Yujia, and she is a well-deserved success in my mind.

594 Upvotes
15 Comments
Add
Original
vertically and horizontally

Because you can't share, you can only resonate.

When you were in elementary school, you thought I would tell you a few words, and after you understood them thoroughly, you would go directly to the university entrance examination in a few days?

The financial industry is the most "advanced" of all industries, and foreign exchange also belongs to the pyramid category in finance. If you understand him, do you think sharing methods and strategies will be enough?​​

Because failure is the only way for every trader who wants to be successful. I will tell you about each of the eighty-one difficulties, and only tell him where you have a bottleneck. He has resonance, he has also experienced it, and he can tell you how he passed this difficulty. ​

In my first year in the industry, I thought that if a master gave me a set of indicators, I could use this thing as a cash machine. Later, I found out that it was too naive. All indicators are for you to understand the shape rules of the K-line more clearly. With a very good trading system and trading strategy, you have to keep trying, failing, trying again, and failing again. In every failure, you have to summarize your mistakes and summarize your personal weaknesses, personality, temper, Xinxing and so on. Through a lot of successes and failures, you also have a sense of the disk, and you are clear about the mistakes and weaknesses, and then break through one by one. This is a long and patient thing.

My cousin learned from me for a month before. He only wanted to earn thirty or forty dollars a day. It was really not difficult, but he didn’t learn or ask at all, as if waiting for the sky to fall. After I taught him the basic framework, he would never He didn’t ask me anything, even if he placed an order, he didn’t tell me or ask. After a month, the money was lost, and then he told me that he was not suitable for this job, and he couldn’t make money doing this. It’s a mess.

Since then, I don't want to teach anyone anymore. If anyone asks me for advice, I will give a concise answer. I will also talk about this when chatting with friends who do this, but the chat has almost nothing to do with the market, because everyone’s approach is different, but the mood is the same​. Originally doing this is quite lonely. When talking about this resonates, my heart also some comfort

147 Upvotes
12 Comments
Add
Original
apricot lotus

Why should I teach you the system that can really make money? How much did you pay for it? 10,000, 100,000, 1 million, 10 million, 100 million? After mastering the method of making money, do you think he can't make money with the money you give? Since he can make money, why should he risk the system failure to teach you?

835 Upvotes
11 Comments
Add
Original
鑫道黄金

The core of real money cannot be shared!

Everyone has weaknesses, and any economic system has weaknesses, and that's often the most indestructible point.
——The highest level of Soros
trading is outside the market. This state cannot be shared.
A successful trader's trading system is like a machine. They can make profits by themselves and have nothing to do with the market. It is difficult for many investors to understand this sentence. People always ask me: "If the market is right, you will make money, if you buy wrong, you will lose. How can you say how much it has to do with the market?" I usually laugh at such words, because I know that he will still lose money, and there is still a long time to go. The road of great loss is to go.
Wall Street once conducted an experiment: let 100 investors conduct transactions strictly in accordance with fund management, buy up and down at will, and after a year, almost all of them finally made stable profits.
This example is enough to show that you can make stable money by focusing your energy outside the market.
Gold investment itself is operating capital, and the core of capital operation lies in fund management. Learning technology and judging the market is just a means of managing funds, not the essence of managing funds. Otherwise, your investment profit will be accidental, and the next time the market is wrong, you will lose all your money.
It is true that technical analysis is more conducive to successful trading, but blindly pursuing technical analysis and getting stuck in the market will make you unable to succeed for a lifetime.
For example, Buffett is a value investor, and it is easier to succeed by studying and judging fundamentals than blindly relying on technology. So have you ever seen someone who has succeeded completely relying on technical analysis?
Let's take a look:
Granby, the inventor of the moving average system buying method (Granby's Eight Rules), eventually went bankrupt and left the market;
Eliot, the inventor of the wave theory, was just an accountant and had never done stocks in his life. His successor, Robert Jr. .Pratchett, after the U.S. stock market plummeted in 1987, he gave speeches every day saying that the U.S. stock market would enter a long-term bear market, and he was short-selling for a long time. As a result, the U.S. stock market quickly hit a new high and rose for 13 years. He lost a lot of money and then disappeared. .
The inventor of Gann's theory came up with a lot of complicated theories, including angles, quadrilaterals, hexagons, and astrology... As a result, Gann went bankrupt in his later years and was destitute.
Jesse Livermore, regarded as the best trader on Wall Street, went bankrupt and committed suicide in his later years.
Dennis, the founder of the famous turtle trading rules, left the market after a 60% loss after the stock market crash in 1987.

these are all technical analysis tools that everyone has been chasing after. Has the person who invented these tools succeeded?
No, so who succeeded?
Buffett, Soros, Rogers.
What is their path to success? Do people rely on technology? Don't be stupid, people don't have time to watch the market all day long like you.
Where Buffett has achieved is in stocks. On the one hand, his method of making profits is to make full use of fundamentals and unique stock selection vision, and on the other hand, he has a strong investment style of pursuing safety with insurance funds.
Soros' achievement lies in highly leveraged foreign exchange. Soros put forward the theory of reflexivity. He believed that due to the group blindness of investors, the market is often wrong, and traders should use the market's mistakes to trade. The theory of reflexivity is the foundation of Soros Forex.
Rogers' achievement is in highly leveraged commodity markets. He uses value investment in the futures market, which is dominated by trend trading. He often sees the long-term value growth trend of a certain commodity, and then conducts medium-term operations.
Do you understand now?
Is the ultra-short-term also successful? Is there any success relying solely on technology?
Buffett's path to success: medium and long-term operation + value investment.
The Soros Path to Success: The Theory of Opposites.
Rogers' success path: value investment + mid-term operation + trend.
And those who pursue short-term and blindly pursue technology may be able to make profits at the beginning, but it does not rule out that there is an element of luck. Once the luck is not there, the whole army will eventually be wiped out!
There are many stars in the capital market, but few birthday stars. In the end, it is success to keep profits. In passing, I don't think it should be what everyone wants.
What can really be achieved is outside the market, and whether it can make a profit has nothing to do with analyzing the market. So what if the analysis is right, it’s just that you made a short-term lucky profit, can you continue to be lucky? So what keeps you lucky? Of course not the market. No matter how good your skills are, can you surpass Granville, Gann, and Dennis?
Technology is inherently uncertain. No matter how well you learn it, it cannot give you enough confidence to fully believe that it can make stable profits. Naturally, it cannot keep you in a good state of mind to perform rigid operations. Even if the technology is 99%, there will always be a time when you will lose everything.
So what can guarantee that you will not go bankrupt? Since technology cannot do it, you must shift your focus. How do successful people do it?
The highest level of stable profit is outside the market.
So how can you have the realm outside the plate?
First, you need to have a rigid analysis system, instead of using technical tools to guess more and more. The "Wall Street Journal" has such an argument - no matter how refined the technology is, its essence is guesswork.
Second, the rigid analysis system must be simple, allowing you to see the buying and selling points at a glance, instead of drawing too many auxiliary lines to rely on analysis. The more complex the more error prone.
Thirdly, the rigid analysis system itself is a fixed mode of reflecting the market. You don’t need to use your brain to think about whether it is going up or down.
Fourth, you also need to have a rigid operating system. The more rigid the analysis system is, the more rigid the operating system can be fed back. Like a machine, it's like laying a trap for the market. If it gets in, you will make a profit, and if you don't get in, you will wait.
There is a famous Wall Street saying: Every successful trader has his own trading system.
The trading system is based on various analysis methods and fund management. It allows you to repeat every simple action, just like a machine that can run automatically with a little oil. It's like setting a trap for the market, all you have to do is sit on the sidelines and wait for the rabbit.

793 Upvotes
9 Comments
Add
Original
warren trading institute

Really successful foreign exchange traders spend money on professional learning and have long-term practical experience. As a result, there is a complete set of trading system to achieve stable long-term profit and finally succeed.

A successful trader always prepares in advance and uses his perfect trading system to capture every good trading opportunity.

Ordinary investors only care about the ups and downs of the market, and they don't understand the market.

Successful trading comes from spending money to learn professional systems and training, plus long-term practice! In addition, I spend a certain amount of time every day: (1) watching important financial data every day (2) using my own perfect trading system to switch between large and small time periods to capture and layout market buying and selling points, stop profit and stop loss points (3) risk Management and position control and mentality, etc.

The above 3 points are necessary for successful traders. Even if successful traders share it with ordinary investors, they may not necessarily learn it! Usually some successful traders succeed by spending money to learn! Currently popular trading methods in the market, harmonic trading, and institutional order principles are tools for excellent traders on Wall Street in Europe and America!

To sum up, if you want to become a successful trader, you must learn from successful traders and spend money on professional training to improve your trading system!

668 Upvotes
9 Comments
Add
Original
shepherd

Everyone has their own reasons for success, which is also the painstaking efforts of other people's loneliness and pain, just like their own children. In addition, even if everyone can write a book, scholars may not necessarily learn it, and in the end, malicious people will say a few unpleasant words, and it is hard to say that some unpleasant things will happen. This is not carrying beans Looking for a pot to fry, why bother?

Besides, the transaction has been successful, and the transaction is only responsible to oneself, so there is no room for arguing, the transaction is successful, it is tantamount to knowing the destiny, and it is tantamount to listening. Will accept apprentices but will never share. To be honest, there are only two types of people on the market who are willing to share, one is not their own hard work, that is to borrow other people's technology. Second, what is shared is only a method and an indicator, not a system.

Real people see fate! This is a real person...

190 Upvotes
9 Comments
Add
Original
why name

Not not to share. Because people who come here feel that they have nothing to share.

Because the methods, strategies and techniques used by successful people have been written in textbooks, such as "Technical Analysis of Futures Market", "Technical Analysis of Futures Trading", "Japanese Candle Chart Technique", "Turtle Trading Rules", etc.

What the successful people do is to repeatedly practice and think about the techniques in these books over the years, and finally understand the meaning of the books and use them proficiently.

431 Upvotes
8 Comments
Add
Original
@彭于晏

Financial traders spend a lot of time learning their craft.

As with any profession, those who practice it (whether lawyers, doctors, engineers, architects) have spent many years learning their profession and their skills. It is simply not possible to provide "important" information to others quickly.

Professional financial traders are no exception. They will spend at least a year or two learning the fundamentals of macroeconomics before undertaking a graduate program or training program with a specialist firm or proprietary trading desk.

Financial traders don't give anything away for free.

Given their training in finance, financial traders know the value of their time and money better than anyone. They're not simply giving it away for free.

Financial traders are not necessarily the best teachers.

Just because someone is a successful, professional financial trader doesn't automatically make them a good teacher.

Transaction size; teaching no.

If a financial trader can make $250 a week from the financial markets for a year's worth of work, why would they trade that (no pun intended) to teach full time? Even if you assume a financial trader can charge $2500 per student, they would need to get 100 students to match their current income.

In practice, the quality of teaching would be poor because one financial trader would be spread over so many students that the trader would have to bring in others to help with teaching. Profits suffer and traders end up earning less than they would when trading the financial markets.

750 Upvotes
7 Comments
Add
Original
kim seung ho talks about gold

Trader for two years! How can we continue to make stable profits?

There is a topic in the circle of students, how to make sustainable and stable profits? For novice traders, I personally have two suggestions:

1: on your own

No one will invest at birth. Most people come from the stage of ignorance. From knowing nothing to knowing astronomy and geography, relying on personal research requires a lot of money. It is an exaggeration to say that the trading books I have read are higher than my own. It took me more than three years just to review the market. Finally, I found a trading system that fits my personality. Strict implementation-trial and error- Execution, left back to achieve stability, I have put all the books I read before and review ideas in the above article, and you can see it when you read forward

Trading is a very complicated subject that requires you to understand economics, politics, and culture; you need to understand major domestic and international news events, and even basic knowledge of physical, chemical and geography. In addition, you also need to understand trading concepts, trading risk control, trading techniques, and trading psychology. In the process of creating trading rules tailored for you, most people will give up or be forced to give up, and the last one is the king. If the time is short, it may be stable in three to five years, and if the time is long, it may not be able to get out of the magic pool of losses for a lifetime. Although the process is suffering, as long as you are good at thinking and self-disciplined enough, it is not difficult to make profits.

 2: rely on others

It costs a lot to think about it by yourself, and most people can't afford the loss of funds and the passage of time, so there is a shortcut to stand on the shoulders of giants. Find a person who has achieved stable trading, copy him, imitate him, and finally create your own trading system on the premise of your own personality. I think this is more cost-effective for traders who are not from a professional background.

For example, if you invest in stocks, you have to pay a lot of money and you may not be able to make progress. It is better to copy the homework of outstanding investors, find those who have been proven to have good historical performance, think about what they think, and think about what they think , do what they do, and finally use it for you. For example, Hillhouse, Gao Yi, Danshuiquan, Ruiyuan, Lin Yuan, etc., find a role model that suits your personality, imitate him, and get to know him well. After all, only a good method can produce the power of redemption!

Is it reliable to buy programs and rely on automatic trading by machines?

Some readers asked whether the "EA" program strategy is easy to use? Because there are always some people in the market who make a living by selling programs, and claim that their programs can achieve a certain annualized rate. .

I believe that veterans will have different feelings when they see EA - many people have bought the program, there are many people who make short-term profits, and none of the final endings escape the ending of liquidation!

Take Martin as an example. Many people package the Martin program as a 100% profit-making strategy. Let’s think about it. Unless your principal is infinitely large, or your position must be infinitely small. If you really make money, you will get 10% every time you lose a few thousandths. Second fill, isn't it embarrassing? If you want to take a bigger position, if you catch an extreme market, your account will explode on the spot! Some people say that our Martin can carry a "stop loss", think about it. . . Does it make sense? This kind of program is originally a doubling gambling strategy. What does it mean to have a stop loss? Is there something wrong? . . . . . I once asked my IT staff to conduct a systematic calculation of this strategy. No matter what risk control strategy you add to this strategy, the final result will be a liquidation! But sooner or later!

If you want to achieve stable profits, you cannot do without the above two processes. One is to study yourself and the other is to study others. In the end, you can achieve the goal of stability! It's too late, so I won't say much, tomorrow I will talk about those so-called "reproducible" trading systems in detail in combination with the real offer in the article!

Author: Kim Seung-ho

Learn the correct trading ideas and capture market trends in advance!

617 Upvotes
7 Comments
Add
Original
分子交易12

The establishment of the trading model has a lot to do with the traders themselves. There are 1000 Hamlets in the hearts of 1000 people. There is no identical leaf in the world. We must always allow individual differences. What suits me may not suit you, and what suits you may not suit TA.

Many traders are constantly looking for the Holy Grail of the market. Is there a Holy Grail? Each trading model will have certain applicability. For example, Americans use more Google search engines. If you change the market, it will not work in mainland China. The United States uses Facebook and Twitter. Trump just likes Twitter politics, and China uses Weibo and WeChat. It's not that Weibo and WeChat are better than Facebook and Twitter, but that they have different adaptability and national conditions. It's not that one trick is popular everywhere, and all roads lead to Rome.

It's not that the trading system cannot be shared, even if you share it, you may not understand it, if you understand it, you may not be able to use it, and if you know how to use it, you may not be able to use it well.

I brought an apprentice before, and I told him the trading system after I hadn’t learned it for a long time. I said I told him: you can’t copy my trading system. He doesn't believe it. He had a background in numerical control and technology before, and he could make something after reading it once. good! I told the whole story about my trading system, and he made a mess of it.

Everyone's understanding of trading will be different, which is why so many people are long and so many are short. What we see is the same board, the same thing, why does everyone have a different understanding? This is called a cognitive bias. The establishment of the trading system is related to one's own trading experience.

669 Upvotes
6 Comments
Add
Original
汇市飞翔

How do you count as success? Is it huge profits or stable profits?

It is meaningless to share short-term huge profits. Sooner or later, the position will be liquidated. Any method can make a few occasional huge profits, so why bother to share.

A stable profit of about 30% a year is very good. This profit rate is dismissive to most people who do foreign exchange, thinking that a year's profit is not as good as his one-day profit. Let more people reject and disdain. Why listen to other people's sarcastic remarks.

Just make money yourself, and stable profits are better than anything else.

855 Upvotes
5 Comments
Add
Original
慕来交易学院

People live in this world, what they seek are two things: either "fame" or "profit".

The real stable and profitable trading system, profit-seeking people will not teach you, what they teach you must not be profitable, this is deterministic, so when I met those who told me that they were stable and profitable, they wanted to take you to make money, or guided you in other ways If you make money with him, you can almost be identified as a liar. Maybe he has a very beautiful rhetoric, but if you try carefully what he taught you, in the application market, you can still tell whether it is right or not. I believe you can still tell the difference .

What about those who ask for a "name"?

This is difficult to define, for example, myself, I am now looking for "fame", the students are all over the country, and have trained many talents, including some foreign students. Approved. Our purpose is also very clear, to make a revolution in the trading world, and to convey a trading concept that truly starts from the essence of the market. The current Chinese trading world is really mixed, and few people really understand trading. All I learn are trading techniques that deviate from the market, which is why more than 90% of my friends are struggling with repeated losses.

Everyone has ideals, and our ideal is to change the status quo! disseminate correct knowledge

402 Upvotes
5 Comments
Add
Original
aunt yuzhu

I don't know how to count success

I feel successful when I take care of myself🕵🏻‍♀️

877 Upvotes
4 Comments
Add
Original
qkenping

Would you casually trust a stranger's strategy? Since no one will believe it when you say it, why bother to be passionate!

What's more, knowledge is paid, so why do people just say so casually the knowledge they have learned so hard.

Doesn't it look cheaper!

867 Upvotes
4 Comments
Add
Original
chief sleep expert at ma jiao institute of technology

    Do you think that those trading strategy books on the market do not exist? As far as I know, many successful traders end up on the road of publishing books and teaching. Of course, some people do it to make money, and some people do it to cheat money. Unsuccessful traders like me are also happy to share and discuss with you, and those successful traders are more willing to share their methods, strategies and even ideas. On the other hand, those who are secretive about trading methods, who are self-conscious and even have to pay a lot of money to transfer them are often liars, so you must keep your eyes open.

    Because a successful, proven and practical trading method or strategy will definitely bring continuous huge profits to the trader, so that he has nothing to ask for in terms of benefits, and the rest is to seek fame. Soros has also published a bunch of books. Although Buffett has not published a book, he has also shown his ideas in many books written by others. As their trading ideas spread, so did their names. There are also exceptions. There is a book called "Ghosts of Wall Street" that talks about trading ideas. The author has always refused to disclose his name. It is also like my country's "Tang Zhong Lun Zen". So far, netizens have not been able to determine who he is. People like this share selflessly Those who don't even keep their names because of their own trading principles, and don't even have the desire to be famous, can be called saints.

    From another perspective, it is not that successful traders do not share their methods and strategies, but that "the speaker has the heart, but the listener has no intention." Many novice traders always have a "holy grail" plot. They think that successful traders must have their secrets. The so-called "pass one sentence, pass thousands of books". "True biography". A new trader always hopes that an old man with a white beard will fall from the sky, and explain to him in three sentences that he must do this first, then this, and then this, so that he can wait for his account to increase dozens of times. It's useless, the more earnestly you tell him, the more he thinks that you are covering up your real trading secrets, which is hopeless.

    Having said that, there is no completely correct trading method that is universally applicable in the world, only the method that suits you. No matter how successful the strategy is, it is only suitable for the winner himself, and if another person does it, he may suffer a complete failure. Therefore, as a junior in the trading field, you must learn more and read more, fully absorb the experience and lessons of the predecessors and summarize them into your own trading system and trading philosophy, so that you can truly succeed. As the Sixth Patriarch Hui Neng said, what can be told to you will not be a secret. If you can reflect on yourself and achieve something, then you will have your own secret.

835 Upvotes
4 Comments
Add
Original
sunflower samurai

The big guy may have made a few major deals right by relying on his intuition, and then he just continued to control the risk and gradually made a fortune on the basis of these lucky few times. Fortunately, the standard configuration of success cannot be shared.

627 Upvotes
4 Comments
Add
Original
king of karaoke

First of all, I will definitely not tell others how I make money. I will only talk about my ideas in general. These same things, how to enter the market, how to hold orders, and how to exit the market, these judgments will definitely not be shared for no reason.

Secondly, a stable profit system includes a premise of screening the market, most of the time it is outside the market, and novices can't stand this, when the market is specious, they will estimate how the market will go, and then enter the market blindly; Because stable traders have their own system, they know the retracement of this system and the profit rate, so they will be patient in dealing with the market, decisive when they should make a move, and wait patiently when they should not enter the market. Novices like to predict and judge by themselves , Conjecture, veterans pay attention to the market that is happening, so it is meaningless to share it! You tell him your method, as long as he thinks your method is not good once, he will deny this method, because this is not the method he summed up by himself, and he has no systematic experience!

592 Upvotes
4 Comments
Add
Original

About

0

work

0

subscriber

About Us User AgreementPrivacy PolicyRisk DisclosurePartner Program AgreementCommunity Guidelines Help Center Feedback
App Store Android

Risk Disclosure

Trading in financial instruments involves high risks including the risk of losing some, or all, of your investment amount, and may not be suitable for all investors. Any opinions, chats, messages, news, research, analyses, prices, or other information contained on this Website are provided as general market information for educational and entertainment purposes only, and do not constitute investment advice. Opinions, market data, recommendations or any other content is subject to change at any time without notice. Trading.live shall not be liable for any loss or damage which may arise directly or indirectly from use of or reliance on such information.

© 2025 Tradinglive Limited. All Rights Reserved.